So who’d have thunk it? Bobby Valentine is more polarizing a topic in Boston than the political merits of Sarah Palin, the legacy of Roger Moore’s James Bond and who’d play (JF) Kennedy if Hollywood made a biopic tomorrow (afterMoneyball, I’d cast Jonah Hill. Just because.)
In fact, most of us would’ve thunk it, quite frankly. But, whilst we all suspected that dropping the erstwhile firecracker into one of the most volatile media markets in the world was bound to be problematic. We didn’t figure just how quickly, and how badly, “Bobby V” would rub people up the wrong way. And nobody had money on his own players being his first targets.
Here’s the deal. After being in Boston for about three minutes, Valentine dealt with his first major situation: an injury to closer Andrew Bailey. The closer is never an easy position to replace in baseball, and for the Sox, this was exacerbated by the fact that one of the contenders to do just that, Daniel Bard, has recently been promoted to the starting rotation this year. So moving him in as cover would be the Red Sox version of robbing Peter to pay Paul.
One of the candidates to replace Bailey, Mark Melancon, by no means a green-gilled rookie, received less than glowing support from his new boss after being given a shot at landing the position. How did Bobby V rate his possible solution?
“I thought he backed up the bases really well,” Valentine said. “He had that down.”
Which is baseball’s equivalent of a guy saying to his friends: “She wasn’t much to look at, but she had a so/so personality. I guess.”
Melancon is now plying his trade in Triple AAA Pawtucket. It’s all character building stuff, of course. This is where ESPN America is sending me next week.
But Valentine’s (mis)handling of one of his closers is nothing compared to how he treated one of Boston’s favorite sons Kevin “God of Walks” Youkilis this week. At least, that’s what everyone would have you believe.
Valentine’s calling out of Youk’s commitment, “I don’t think he’s as physically or emotionally into the game as he has been in the past for some reason” – has been widely ridiculed as the ill-judged rantings of a mad man, by fans, media and in one instance Bobby’s own charges:
”I don’t really understand what Bobby’s trying to do. But that’s really not the way we go about our stuff here. I’m sure he’ll figure that out soon.” So said Dustin Pedroia. The second baseman leapt to the defense of his teammate and very publicly slapped his skipper on the wrist at the same time.
Interestingly though, the next part of his interview suggests Pedroia may have unwittingly stumbled upon a logical reason for his manager’s comments: “We feel we have a good team and we’ve just got to get each others’ backs and play together. Because if you don’t do that, I don’t care what sport you’re playing, you’re not going to win.”
As a player Bobby V spent the majority of his career in California and New York, where he also managed for six years. This is the guy chosen by one of the most powerful, and richest, sporting franchises in the world to be the public face of their team in 2012.
And his time in Japan – despite Pedroia’s startling assertion that somehow this was a disadvantage in terms of managing in the majors – probably taught him a thing or two about how to acclimatize to a new, unusual situation.
Does anyone honestly think he’s as naïve as he’s been made out to be in terms of dealing with the media?
Valentine knows exactly what he’s doing – and his inflammatory remarks, in terms of intention anyway, are carefully crafted to get the team playing for each other. Look at the situation he inherited: a team of highly paid superstars who are underachieving (again).
“Big management” – that is, the steering of mega star teams – is becoming more and more prevalent in contemporary sports, as teams assemble rosters or squads of multiple elite players – be it Manchester City, Miami Heat or the Red Sox. And there isn’t one blueprint to show you how to navigate – not least because every situation is inevitably different, given it’s by definition, character driven by the specific personnel assembled at that time.
Valentine has lost the locker room already, they say. Yeah, and Tony La Russa was past it last season, too. And Mariano can’t close any more. And blah, blah, blah.
Predictably enough, though, our breakneck pace generation has already written off his time in Boston before it’s even begun. The season is 13 games old. Judge Valentine when it’s all said and done. (Note to self. Judge Valentine could be a good TV vehicle for Bobby if he does get axed. Like Judge Judy, only Dustin Pedroia is on trial every show).































![carl-crawford.2[1]](http://www.teawithtlr.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/carl-crawford.21.jpg)
![larussa_2[1]](http://www.teawithtlr.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/larussa_21.jpg)



